Monday, March 30, 2009
Public Favors 36% Cap On Consumer Loans, Survey Finds
Such a cap has been introduced in both the U.S. Senate and House as one strategy for helping to restore the health of our economy and financial systems. Senator Dick Durbin, (D-IL) introduced S500 in late February and Representative Jackie Speier (D-CA) followed suit in the House last week, introducing H.R. 1608.
The Center for Responsible Lending supports a 36 percent cap on annual interest rates as a measure that would contribute to economic recovery efforts by ending high-interest credit schemes that trap working families in debt. The cap is the only reform that has been effective in stopping payday lenders from trapping their customers in long-term debt at annual rates of 400 percent.
"A 36 percent cap on annual interest for consumer credit is a quick, common-sense way to restore protections that have been severely compromised in the consumer credit market," said CRL president Michael Calhoun. "It would cost taxpayers nothing and plug a $5 billion hole in the wallets of working families."
In the CRL survey, most respondents, 82 percent, voted in last year's presidential election. Only 25 percent thought there should be no cap on interest rates at all.
Congress passed a 36 percent cap in 2006 to protect active members of the military after the Pentagon testified that payday loans were affecting military readiness. Ohio, Arkansas, New Hampshire, and Arizona are among states that recently revoked exemptions from usury caps their lawmakers had given payday lenders. State lawmakers reimposed the usury cap after seeing firsthand the harm payday lending inflicts on borrowers, who typically can't escape quickly from such high-cost debt. But 35 states have yet to pass reforms that stop such practices.
The federal measure would give all citizens an equal measure of protection from what can only be described as legal loan-sharking, but also would allow state lawmakers to set even stronger protections if they deemed it necessary. Arkansas limits interest to 17 percent within its state constitution, New York makes interest above 25 percent a criminal offense, and Ohio passed a 28 percent cap last year, which was affirmed by voters in a ballot measure in November. A federal cap would not alter these state protections.
Payday loans are marketed as an advance on a borrower's next paycheck, but the terms of these small loans are designed to keep borrowers paying high interest payments over long periods of time without paying off the loan or even paying down the principal.
"Recent research links predatory products like payday lending to bankruptcy, closed bank accounts, credit card delinquency and a long list of other financial hardships," Calhoun said. "There is really no excuse for failing to stop these abuses now, for the sake of working families across the nation, and for the sake of our economic stability. We see where lax consumer protections led us in the mortgage market. We should learn from that hard-taught lesson."
For more details on the survey please visit: http://www.responsiblelending.org/issues/payday/reports/interest-rate-survey.html.
Source - www.foxbusiness.com
Sunday, March 29, 2009
State Trying to Protect Consumers
On Tuesday morning, the state Office of the Attorney General filed one lawsuit against seven Internet payday lenders and a second lawsuit against five collection agencies.
According to Assistant Attorney General Norman Googel, the office received complaints indicating that each company was either making or collecting Internet payday loans in West Virginia. The companies are Cash Advance Now, Debt Doctor, Direct ROI, E Smart Credit Network, Island Payday, Platinum Finance Company, Sonic Cash, A.C.A. Recovery, Capital Collections, Covenant Management Group, Oasis Financial Solutions and Westbury Ventures.
“There may be hundreds of West Virginia consumers who have taken loans,” he said.
The 12 companies refused to comply when the attorney general issued an investigative subpoena requiring them to produce records of their lending and collection activities in the state, Googel said. Because those entities would not respond to the subpoena, the office proceeded to ask the court to issue an order demanding that they provide the information.
He said the activities of the companies are unlawful, and they are not licensed to make loans in the state. The attorney general’s office also requested that the court prohibit them from making and collecting Internet payday loans in West Virginia.
Googel explained that payday loans are short-term loans, usually for two weeks, that are awarded with no real credit check and expected to be repaid by the next payday. Loans issued through check cashing stores are the classic form of payday lending. At these places — which West Virginia doesn’t have — consumers borrow small amounts of money, usually $200 or $300, using a post-dated check, he said.
Generally within 14 days, the borrower must pay off the amount plus interest rates. If the person is not able to make the payment in time, more fees are added and continue to pile on for every two weeks the money is late.
Googel said consumers typically don’t have the money to pay the loan back. So to prevent their check from being cashed and their account from bouncing, they keep returning to the storefront every two weeks to pay the interest. This dangerous pattern leads them into a debt trap.
“They’ll go out and get other payday loans to pay off the first one,” he said. “They’re getting wiped out and it actually can lead consumers to foreclosure.”
Even though payday lending is illegal in West Virginia and other states, the industry has tried to find ways to get around the laws, he said.
For instance, consumers who need cash can go online to apply for Internet payday loans. Because consumers get these loans while on their home computers in West Virginia, the lenders are in fact subject to the state’s laws, Googel said.
He said Internet payday lenders deposit money into a consumer’s account and the consumer agrees to repay the amount plus interest in two weeks. The person gives the company permission to electronically debit the fee out of his or her account in 14 days.
Consumers are told that they aren’t allowed to stop those debits, which Googel said is also a sham, and they fear that if they don’t pay they’ll get in trouble.
“Until they get to (the attorney general’s office), they don’t know that they can stop it,” he said. “You have a right to stop the debits, and you need to do it right now. They just need to close their checking account and open a new one with a new number.”
Googel encouraged consumers who are victims of Internet payday lenders to contact the Consumer Protection Hotline at 1-800-368-8808 or visit www.wvago.gov to file complaints.
Even if on paper the individual hasn’t paid the loan, he or she owes nothing because the loan is unlawful, he said. The attorney general’s office will back the consumer 100 percent on this, track down the company, and help fix the problem.
“We really urge people not to get these loans because it is a trap, but we know that many more thousands have probably gotten them,” Googel said. “We want them to please call us. We’re glad to talk to anybody that is having problems with Internet payday loans. We really want to educate the public.”
McGraw’s office has been actively investigating Internet payday lending since about 2005.
“A lot of states are really looking to us for leadership, and we’re very proud of that,” Googel said. “This (predatory practice) is going on everywhere.”
“It’s a very very shadowy industry, and it operates very much off the grid. The only answer to payday lending is to ban it.”
source - www.timeswv.com
Tuesday, March 17, 2009
Senate bill would give Americans fewer borrowing options
Given the unprecedented lending drought, one might think that policymakers' top priority would be working to restore a fluid credit market. President Barack Obama has said that in stimulating the economy, his bottom line "is whether or not credit is flowing to the people who need it."
It boggles the mind then to consider that in the midst of this credit crisis, any legislator would propose to restrict small lines of credit to the neediest Americans. , Sen. Dick Durbin on Feb. 27 filed a bill, S. 500, that would establish a national interest-rate cap on consumer-credit transactions, a restriction that would eliminate some of the last remaining sources of loans available to families with few alternatives.
Durbin's plan to eliminate credit options in a credit crisis is like closing hospitals during a flu epidemic.
The bill would limit short-term loans to a 36 percent annual percentage rate. On the surface, that seems reasonable for loans of 12 to 36 months. But for short-term loans, a 36 percent annual cap equals a $1.38 fee on a two-week $100 loan. You can't sustain a business by lending money to strangers with bad credit if you can charge them only 10 cents per day.
Durbin said in his floor speech that "if a lender can't make money on 36 percent interest, then maybe the loan shouldn't be made." But in his rush to make headlines, the senator misses the point and the math entirely. Annualized interest rates are appropriate for loans with long terms, but are nonsensical for loans with a two-week period.
Equating the interest rates on loans with drastically different terms leads to absurd conclusions. In the rest of our society, short-term options cost more than long-term options, and no one bats an eye. Is Holiday Inn a "predatory hotel" because it charges $154 per night? Compared with the cost of a year-long apartment lease, Holiday Inn's $4,620 per month looks outright extortionate. You can rent a studio apartment in most cities across America for about $500 per month. Using the same price cap proposed for short-term loans, the $154 room rate should be set a maximum of $16 per night.
A $16 limit wouldn't technically be a ban, but the semantics wouldn't matter to hotels driven out of business. Short-term "payday" loans are no different: a 36 percent annual-percentage-rate limit is prohibition, plain and simple.
Regulation certainly has its place, but it doesn't have to mean heavy-handed elimination of financial options. Consumer-friendly disclosure rules provide information on fees and charges. With the right information, consumers can choose the option that's best for them.
Former Democratic Presidential nominee George McGovern wrote last year, "After a lending ban, the consumer has the same amount of debt but fewer ways to manage it." Durbin would do well to heed his party elder's advice.
source - www.orlandosentinel.com
Short-term payday loans aren't cheap, and they aren't the best choice for every situation. But short-term credit is a lifeline for millions of American families. Lawmakers shouldn't take it away without carefully considering the consequences, especially at a time when so many credit options are drying up.
Tim Miller is the communications director for the Center for Consumer Freedom, a 501(c)3 nonprofit organization that promotes personal responsibility and protecting consumer choices.
Local lawmaker going after payday lending
State Senator Robert Ford supports a proposed Senate bill that will limit the amount of money people can borrow to 25% of their gross paycheck.
Borrowers would also have to pay off their first loan and wait seven days before getting a second loan.
The payday lending industry feels they're being pushed out of the state.
But Windell Shackleford said the state should regulate the industry.
Spokesman for Advance America Jamie Fulmer said the House is already trying to pass a bill that addresses consumer issues, while allowing people to make their own financial decision.
"The bill also mandates an extended payment plan for consumers who cannot repay their loans on time. There would be no additional fees for this service," said Fulmer in a statement.
Less than 3 percent of Advance America's customers do not repay their loans, he added.
Shackleford felt betrayed by the industry. He says he's an Iraqi veteran who fell on hard times emotionally and financially so he was forced to live in his car.
He used his car's title to borrow $700 in September 2008. Months later, Shackleford felt behind on his payments, so he tried to get another loan to pay for the first one.
Instead, Shackleford said he was tricked. His car was taken right as he was taking out the second loan.
"They want these people to be going from payday to payday to payday loans, borrowing this money [they] cannot pay back, but paying those high interest rates in the mean time," Ford said. "We don't want to run them out of town, we want to regulate them."
"We are desperate," said Shackleford. "We don't really know what we get ourselves into because of finance difficulties. We grab anything."
Windell thinks he'll likely lose his car.
source - www.live5news.com
Senators rightly propose tough payday loan rules
A Senate subcommittee approved a bill that would limit the size of payday loans to 25 percent of a borrower’s gross income, require a seven-day cooling-off period between loans, limit consumers to one outstanding loan at a time and require a database to track loans.
As encouraging as the subcommittee action was, there’s much work to be done. It’s imperative that the Banking and Insurance Committee and the full Senate ignore payday lenders’ attempts to kill this bill.
This is far superior to the flimsy bill passed by the House that would limit payday loans to one at a time but double the amount to $600. The bill, like the Senate proposal, creates a database. But the House measure does nothing to prevent flipping, or a series of repeated loans that create a cycle of debt. The Senate subcommittee’s seven-day cooling-off period and limit on the number of loans a borrower can have at once would do more to keep people from being caught in a debt trap.
Expect a fierce fight in the Senate. Payday lenders doled out hundreds of thousands of dollars in donations to lawmakers and payments to lobbyists over the past year in an effort to get favorable treatment in the Legislature. After having had their way with the House, the lenders are claiming the Senate subcommittee’s measure would kill their business. In other words, they don’t want to operate in a state unless allowed to make obscene profits by fleecing unprotected borrowers.
All the Senate subcommittee bill would do is restrict lenders to what they have long contended — or is it pretended? — is their goal: providing emergency loans to people for a car repair or a bill. The people payday lenders say they’re out to help would fare much better if their loans worked like emergency loans instead of the predatory product that has harmed so many.
According to the Community Financial Services Association, the trade group whose job is to protect payday lending, the industry’s customers are “middle income,” earning between $25,000 and $50,000 a year. That fits the Senate subcommittee’s effort to allow the industry to continue providing emergency loans for folks in that income range without plunging them into debt: To borrow $300, the maximum payday loan available now, a borrower would have to earn $31,200 annually. To borrow $500, the maximum loan under the Senate bill, a borrower would have to earn $52,000.
So, why are the lenders crying foul? Because they don’t make money by helping people out of an emergency here or there. This business thrives by getting people to repeatedly borrow short-term, high-interest loans, with no rules. The lenders make repeated loans to borrowers, many of whom they know can’t repay them. That leads to borrowers continuing to take out loans in an effort to stay ahead, yet never getting there.
These lenders won't give up easily. They’ve sabotaged reasonable rules before, and will try again. Senate Banking and Insurance Committee members must resist attempts by lobbyists and payday lender-friendly lawmakers to water down this legislation.
They must send this bill to the Senate intact. And senators should act decisively in favor of consumers.
source - www.thestate.com
New rules would limit fees companies could charge
There are as many as ten payday loan stores in Guelph.
The businesses advance loans to borrowers -- generally in the amount of $100 to $1,000 -- who then repay the money when they receive their paycheque. Interest rates vary, but can run over 25 per cent.
A sharp reduction in the number of people actually receiving paycheques has reduced the clientele of payday lenders.
Effective April 1, these companies in Ontario will only be allowed to charge $21 for every $100 borrowed. The rate is $17 in Manitoba, $23 in British Columbia and $31 in Nova Scotia.
Ontario is also bringing in prohibitions on "rollover" loans, which allow a consumer to get a second loan from a lender before the first is repaid.
Borrowers will also get a two-day cooling off period to cancel a loan without explanation or penalty.
Capping the fee could force some players out of the game, said Stan Keyes, president of the Canadian Payday Loan Association (CPLA), which represents 20 companies (eight in Ontario) with 550 outlets across Canada. The association lobbied for fee-caps and new regulations.
"As a result of the downturn in the economy, they are seeing a stabilizing in the number of transactions, especially over the last 60 to 90 days," Keyes said.
"That is probably attributable to the fact that, for people who have lost their job, they have no paycheque. You have to have a paycheque to qualify for one of the loans."
Keyes said a number of companies will have to change the way they operate or shut their doors as a result of the rate-cap and new regulations. He said a reduction in the number of payday businesses, of which there are over 120 in Ontario, is inevitable.
"The state of the marketplace, generally speaking, has been one of no growth, at least in the last year and a half or so," said Michael Thompson, senior vice president of The Cash Store, from his office in Edmonton. The company, which is not a CPLA member, has 420 branches in nine provinces and two territories.
"The fact that people have lost their jobs will have an impact on the payday loan business, because most payday loan companies require that people have a job or some form of income in order to get a payday loan," Thompson said. "I would imagine that would have some impact on the business over the next few months, for sure."
Thompson doesn't approve of the Ontario rate-cap measure, and thinks that regulating the industry is enough. He supports the measures to prohibit rollover loans, and to give customers a cooling-off period.
He said there are companies in Ontario that currently charge less than $21 for every $100 borrowed, and they will likely raise their rates to the maximum. Setting a low cap, he said, may not be in the best interests of consumers.
"Our perspective is that the government should be trying to tackle business practices through business regulations that are typical of financial services companies," Thompson said.
source -news.guelphmercury.com
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
Idaho Lawmakers to Consider New Payday Loan Bills
Idaho lawmakers have agreed to consider two bills that would provide a powerful incentive to make sure all payday lenders offering loans to residents are licensed.
Payday lenders provide short-term loans with high interest rates and usually cater to lower-income borrowers. Customers are supposed to repay the loan with their next paycheck. The loans can come at a high price, with most businesses charging about 25 percent interest.
Both bills introduced Tuesday, one in the House and one in the Senate, would invalidate any loan provided by an unlicensed payday lender. They would also allow the state Department of Finance to issue cease and desist orders and to sue unlicensed payday lenders.
In order to operate in Idaho, payday lenders are required to have a lender's license. The problem is that some Internet payday companies are offering loans without getting a license. These bills would give the state the right to say that a loan from an unlicensed lender is invalid.
House Minority Leader Rep. John Rusche, D-Lewiston, said the cease and desist order would keep lenders from harassing Idaho residents.
"Basically it says if you borrow from an unlicensed lender they have no right to collect," Rusche said.
The House bill would also require payday lenders to give consumers a list of credit and debt counseling services and would create an optional payment plan for borrowers who can't pay off the loan.
source - www.forbes.com
Senate Approves Bill on Payday Loans
But Gov. Steve Beshear said he has concerns about the legislation, and his staff will have to review it before deciding whether to oppose it.
Opposition to House Bill 444 in the Senate came from four Democrats and two Republicans. The bill passed by a vote of 32-6.
"I don't think it's a moratorium, I think it's a monopoly," Sen. Robert Stivers, R-Manchester, said in an interview. "I think we ought to be regulating these people more instead of giving them a monopoly."
Sen. Kathy Stein, D-Lexington, explained on the Senate floor that she believes the moratorium on new payday lenders violates both the U.S. and Kentucky constitutions.
The bill now goes back to the House for consideration of Senate changes.
It began as a modest effort to regulate the industry by requiring a state database to track payday loans to ensure that people borrowing from the high-fee lenders have no more than two loans from them totaling no more than $500.
Payday lenders offer the short-term loans to people who often don't qualify for bank loans. It generally costs about $15 for a $100 loan, repayable in two weeks. That translates to 390 percent annual interest.
Last week, the Senate State and Local Government Committee, at the urging of its chairman, Damon Thayer, R-Georgetown, amended the bill to also prohibit any new businesses that offer payday loans for 10 years.
In explaining the amendment, Thayer said it was a bill the check-cashing industry wanted.
"I was told it was an agreed-upon bill by the deferred-deposit industry," he said.
Tres Watson, a spokesman for the Community Financial Services Association of America, which represents payday lenders, said yesterday that his group didn't ask for the legislation but didn't have a problem with it.
Lourdes Baez-Schrader, a spokeswoman for Senate Republicans, then returned the call for him and said she would try to find out who was behind the legislation. She later said the bill was requested by "the little people." She did not elaborate.
Thayer eventually did call back, but said only that he spoke with "numerous people" in the industry who favored the bill. He then refused to answer any other questions.
Richard Beliles, chairman of Common Cause Kentucky, which pushes for open government, said yesterday that it should be a concern when legislators won't say who is behind the bills they push.
"It's not in the public interest," he said.
The bill also is being criticized by a coalition of groups that work on social justice issues. They say passing it would compromise future legislation to rein in the industry.
The Kentucky Coalition for Responsible Lending opposes the bill because it doesn't go far enough in regulating the industry.
Terry Brooks, executive director of Kentucky Youth Advocates, said the coalition wants the legislature to hold off changing laws that relate to payday lenders until it tackles reforming the industry, and limiting interest to 36 percent annually.
The coalition has no position on the moratorium.
Rep. Johnny Bell, D-Glasgow, who introduced HB 444, said he has no problem with the moratorium amendment.
He said he just wants his bill to pass because the state Department of Financial Institutions can't monitor loans to ensure people are not taking out too many for too much money.
Beshear, who during the 1990s was a lobbyist for the industry, said yesterday that he favors the bill, though he is "concerned about the 10-year moratorium."
"I would like to see a strong bill that regulates payday lending in the commonwealth. I think Rep. Bell's bill as it originally started … is at least a step in the right direction," Beshear said.
He said the database Bell's bill creates would immediately eliminate about a quarter of all payday loans.
Of the moratorium, he said: "I'm going to look at it closer. … It bothers me to be putting a restriction like that in there."
Source - www.courier-journal.com
Thursday, March 5, 2009
SCOC Refuses to Hear Payday Loan Case
OTTAWA - The payday loan industry took a major hit Thursday when the Supreme Court of Canada rejected a bid to review a case that could have put in jeopardy class-action lawsuits against high-interest lending companies.
The court, without giving reasons, dismissed an application by National Money Mart Company and its American parent company, Dollar Financial Group Inc., to seek leave to appeal the November 2008 decision of the Ontario Court of Appeal. The province's top court ruled a class-action lawsuit against the payday lender could go ahead despite loan agreements containing arbitration clauses and class-action waivers.
The Ontario court upheld a lower court's decision that dismissed the company's motion to toss out the case involving an estimated 210,000 payday loan borrowers, who allege they were charged illegal interest.
The anti-usury - lending money at an exorbitant interest -provision of Canada's Criminal Code makes it an offence to charge more than 60 per cent interest per annum; some payday loans can accumulate nearly 800 per cent in annual interest.
The payday lender has consistently argued that the class-action suit in Ontario cannot proceed because all loan agreements contain a class-action waiver in favour of arbitration.
Many companies include these clauses in service contracts in the hopes of preventing their customers from launching lawsuits against them if disputes arise.
In this case, National Money Mart banked on two decisions made by the Supreme Court in 2007 to plead its case. In both cases, the court upheld the binding arbitration clauses in terms of service contracts issued by Rogers Wireless Inc. and Dell Computer Corp., disallowing consumer lawsuits against the companies.
Payday lenders have been the targets of class-action suits in several provinces. In Alberta, Cash Store recently settled out of court for $3 million. Last month, a B.C. Supreme Court judge certified a class-action suit against three payday lenders, alleging their fees constitute illegal interest.
The British Columbia government responded this week with the introduction of regulations to cap the interest rate for payday loans at 23 per cent of the principle borrowed, for an accumulated annual interest rate of 600 per cent.
Source - Canwest News Service